Math History Tidbits: The Battling Bernoullis

July 27th is Alex’s birthday. She shares it with Johann Bernoulli, an irascible mathematician from the late 17th century. This coincidence intrigued her enough that she wrote a research paper on Johann and his mathematical brother, titled “Jeering Jacob and Jealous Johann.”

Of course, to make the alliteration work, she had to mispronounce Johann’s name — but she figured he kinda deserved that. Read the historical tidbits below to find out why one writer said the Bernoulli brothers were “the kind of people who give arrogance a bad name.”*

Jacob Bernoulli

Because he was 12 years older, Jacob Bernoulli often called his brother “my pupil.” This was meant to imply that Johann did nothing on his own, but only repeated what Jacob had taught him.

Jacob Bernoulli was one of the first to study the rules of probability. He wrote Ars Conjectandi, which tells how to calculate the probability of success in a series of independent trials (like tossing coins or dice). He proved the Law of Large Numbers: If you make enough trials, your results should closely match the theoretical probability. That may seem obvious, but as Jacob said, “The scientific proof of this principle is not at all simple.”

I recognize the lion by his paw.

Jacob Bernoulli
on reading an anonymous solution to a problem,
which he realized was Isaac Newton’s work

It is utterly implausible that a mathematical formula should make the future known to us, and those who think it can would once have believed in witchcraft.

Jacob Bernoulli
Ars Conjectandi

Even as the finite encloses an infinite series
And in the unlimited limits appear,
So the soul of immensity dwells in minutia
And in the narrowest limits no limit in here.
What joy to discern the minute in infinity!
The vast to perceive in the small, what divinity!

Jacob Bernoulli
Ars Conjectandi

Johann Bernoulli

The Bernoulli brothers were two of the first mathematicians to study Leibniz’s new calculus (published in 1684). Johann became well known as a teacher who could explain this confusing but powerful new math. The first calculus textbook ever published (in 1696) was based on Johann’s lectures — although the author did not acknowledge this, claiming the credit to himself. This of course made Johann mad. But then, jealous Johann often got mad.

The solution “cost me study that robbed me of rest for an entire night.”

Johann Bernoulli
of a problem that stumped mathematicians (including his brother Jacob) for years

But just as much as it is easy to find the differential of a given quantity, so it is difficult to find the integral of a given differential. Moreover, sometimes we cannot say with certainty whether the integral of a given quantity can be found.

Johann Bernoulli
on the simplicity and not-so-simplicity of the calculus

Daniel Bernoulli

Johann Bernoulli had three mathematical sons. The greatest of these was the middle son, Daniel. In 1738, Daniel published his most important work, Hydrodynamica. Johann was so jealous at his son’s success that he wrote and published a similar book the next year. But Johann put a false date on his own book, to make it look like it had been printed five years earlier. He tried to convince people that Daniel had merely copied his book.

Daniel studied the flow of water and other fluids and discovered the Bernoulli Principle, which explains how air pressure lifts an airplane’s wings to make it fly. (Of course, there were no airplanes in those days.)

There is no philosophy which is not founded upon knowledge of the phenomena, but to get any profit from this knowledge it is absolutely necessary to be a mathematician.

Daniel Bernoulli

Other Bernoulli Mathmen

A funny thing about the Bernoulli family is that the fathers kept trying to get their sons to go into business, law, or the church — anything but math!

Johann’s eldest son, Nicolaus II, was his father’s pet. Daniel’s younger brother, Johann II, and his son, Johann III, liked math, too. The latter was a true prodigy, teaching at the Berlin Academy at age 19.

Johann’s youngest grandson, Jacob II, taught at St. Petersburg (where his Uncle Daniel had worked for several years with the famous Leonhard Euler) and married a granddaughter of Euler’s.

Jacob and Johann had a nephew, Nicolaus, who studied probability and edited Jacob’s book Ars Conjectandi. Nicolaus the nephew (Daniel’s cousin) used Jacob’s Law of Large Numbers to estimate the probability of having a boy baby as 18/35, or about 51%.

* William Dunham, The Mathematical Universe.
[Back to top.]

To Be Continued…

Read all the posts from the July/August 1999 issue of my Mathematical Adventures of Alexandria Jones newsletter.

4 thoughts on “Math History Tidbits: The Battling Bernoullis

    1. I thought about that as I was retyping this for the blog post. In their day, it’s quite possible that both of the brothers pronounced their name with a “Y” sound, rather than our Americanized “J”.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.