Playful Math 178: Nicomachus’s Carnival

Playful Math Blog Carnival 178

Welcome to the 178th edition of the Playful Math Education Blog Carnival — a smorgasbord of delectable tidbits of mathy fun. It’s like a free online magazine devoted to learning, teaching, and playing around with math from preschool to high school.

Bookmark this post, so you can take your time browsing.

There’s so much playful math to enjoy!

By tradition, we start the carnival with a puzzle/activity in honor of our 178th edition. But if you’d rather jump straight to our featured blog posts, click here to see the Table of Contents.

Activity: Nicomachus’s Theorem

Welcome to 2025, a perfectly square year — and the only one this century!

2025 = (20 + 25)2

  • When is the next time we’ll have a perfect-square year?
  • Can you find the only perfect square less than 2025 that works by this pattern? When you split the number’s digits into two smaller numbers and square their sum, you get back to that number.

2025 = the sum of all the numbers in the multiplication table, from 1×1 to 9×9

2025 = the sum of the first 9 perfect cubes

  • When is the next time this will happen, that the year is the sum of the first n perfect cubes?

And by Nicomachus’s theorem:

2025 = 13 + 23 + 33 + 43 + 53 + 63 + 73 + 83 + 93
so it must also = (1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5 + 6 + 7 + 8 + 9)2

Try it for yourself with small numbers: Get some blocks, and build the first few perfect cubes. Then see if you can rearrange the block to form the sum of those numbers squared.

Can you show that…

  • 13 = 12
  • 13 + 23 = (1 + 2)2
  • 13 + 23 + 33 = (1 + 2 + 3)2
  • 13 + 23 + 33 + 43 = (1 + 2 + 3 + 4)2
  • 13 + 23 + 33 + 43 + 53 = (1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 5)2

Nicomachus theorem 3D

Older Students: Can you see that the pattern would continue as long as you want? How might you prove that?

Here’s the formula for triangular numbers, to get you started:

(1 + 2 + 3 + … + n) = n(n + 1)/2

Click here for all the mathy goodness!

FAQ: Can I Use Your Books as a Math Curriculum?

Father helping girl with math homework

I recently listened to you on Cindy Rollins’ podcast, and I was captivated by your perspective on math. It was exciting, freeing, and wonder-filled. I would absolutely love to be able to teach in the ways you described.

    We use early-elementary Saxon Math right now, which is thorough, but has SO MUCH to do that I’ve always struggled to do it all. Then I feel like I’m missing things, and I never know quite what is important. And yet, the actual lessons move so slowly that my kids get bored with the repetition.

      I use a published curriculum because I have no idea of an appropriate scope and sequence, or similar flow of learning. With your playful approach to math, how do I know where to start, and what to do each day?

        Do you have a suggested order to approach your books to have a full math approach? A sort of curriculum, per se, using your books.

        [For those who missed my chat with Cindy Rollins about a Charlotte Mason approach to math, you can listen to it here.]

        Continue reading FAQ: Can I Use Your Books as a Math Curriculum?

        FAQ: Real Math for Early Learners

        photo of family hiking a rocky trail

        “I love your image of math as a nature walk. My children are ready to start their homeschooling journey, and I want to put them on the right track from the beginning. How can I help them think about math and problem-solving without using a textbook?”

        The most difficult part of teaching our children real math is to change our own way of thinking about the subject you’ve already taken that step, so it looks like your family’s learning journey is off to a great start.

        [For readers who are wondering what I mean by math as a nature walk, check out this post. You may also enjoy my article on natural learning: Math with Young Children.]

        Continue reading FAQ: Real Math for Early Learners

        Memories: The Oral Story Problem Game

        photo of sheep in a field

        Homeschool Memories…

        Perhaps you’ve heard me mention the oral story problem game. It was one of my favorite ways to get my children thinking about math, back in our early days of homeschooling. We played in the car on the way to soccer practice, or while we washed dishes, or sitting in the lobby waiting for a doctor’s appointment.

        The rules are simple: I’ll make up a math problem for you to solve. And then you make up one for me.

        The kids always loved trying to stump me.

        This problem from Henry Ernest Dudeney’s Amusements in Mathematics reminded me of those days. This is exactly the way my eldest loved to torture me…

        Continue reading Memories: The Oral Story Problem Game

        Start the New Year Right: Playful Math Carnival 177 via Math Hombre

        Talking Numbers from Playful Math Carnival 177

        If you’re looking for an entertaining way to weather the coming storm — or just curious about how learning math could possibly be fun — you’ll definitely want to check out the latest edition of the Playful Math Carnival.

        It’s a collection of awesome blog posts curated by John Golden and published on the Math Hombre website:

        The whole point of the carnival is to show that math doesn’t have to be tedious or repetitive. Through a bunch of fun and engaging posts, we celebrate math that’s playful, creative, and totally relevant to everyday life.

        Because what could be more relevant than having fun while we learn?

        Continue reading Start the New Year Right: Playful Math Carnival 177 via Math Hombre

        Puzzle: Henry Dudeney’s Pebble Game

        photo of girl playing with pebbles on the beach

        English mathematician and puzzle-meister Henry Ernest Dudeney once wrote:

        “It may be said generally that a game is a contest of skill for two or more persons, into which we enter either for amusement or to win a prize. A puzzle is something to be done or solved by the individual.

          “The example that I give here is apparently a game, but, as in every case one player may win if he only play correctly, it is in reality a puzzle. The interest, therefore, lies in attempting to discover the leading method of play.”

          Below is the puzzle game as Dudeney explained it.

          Play it for fun at first, then see if you can solve the puzzle.

          Continue reading Puzzle: Henry Dudeney’s Pebble Game

          Math Games for the Holidays

          Snowman Drive math party game

          Are you looking for fun ways to keep your children busy (and learning!) through the holidays? Here are two printable activity guides you might enjoy:

          Snowman Drive

          Snowman Drive math game book(My newest game activity.)

          Players roll the dice and build their creative snowman (or snowbeast). Will you make a fearless pirate or a dapper aristocrat — or a high-scoring snow spider?

          A Snowman Drive is a family-friendly party that can also serve as a fundraiser for your church, homeschool group, or organization. The Drive consists of several rounds of the Snowman Game played on a single worksheet, with prizes for the top-scoring players and overall champion.

          This activity book includes game instructions and gameboard pages for single-family or group play.

          For ages 5 and up.

          * * *
          Download a PDF preview file.
          * * *
          FORMAT: 13-page printable PDF file with your choice of 8.5″×11″ (letter size) or A4 pages.

          Buy Now

          Christmas Tree Math Games

          Christmas Tree Math Games book(Number play on a triangular hundred chart.)

          Christmas Tree Math Games features 4 easy-to-learn games and 6 additional activities for primary and middle-grade students. All you need is a set of dice and a few colorful markers.

          Math games build mental flexibility and strategic reasoning in players of all ages. And even people who hated math in school can enjoy the friendly challenge of a game.

          These are NOT the typical memory-and-speed-based math games you’ve probably seen online, but true battles of wit and skill (plus a bit of luck).

          Perfect ice-breakers for family gatherings, classroom warmups, or for launching a group game night. You’ll be surprised how much fun thinking hard can be!

          Christmas Tree Math Games includes instructions and tips for the teacher, math game pages for handouts or learning centers, plus a variety of dot-grid journaling paper.

          For ages 6 and up.

          * * *
          Download a PDF preview file.
          * * *
          FORMAT: 30-page printable PDF file with your choice of 8.5″×11″ (letter size) or A4 pages.

          Buy Now

           
          * * *

          Are you looking for more creative ways to play math with your kids? Check out all my books, printable activities, and cool mathy merch at Denise Gaskins’ Playful Math Store. Or join my email newsletter.

          This blog is reader-supported. If you’d like to help fund the blog on an on-going basis, then please join me on Patreon for mathy inspiration, tips, and an ever-growing archive of printable activities.

          “Math Games for the Holidays” copyright © 2024 by Denise Gaskins. Image at the top of the post copyright © prarinya / Depositphotos.

          Charlotte Mason Math: Practical Tips for a Living Math Education

          “Young italian woman with two sleeping children on coast’ painting by August Riedel, public domain

          Focus on the logic of reasoning.

          Correct answers are important, of course, but as children explain their thinking, they will often catch and fix mistakes on their own.

          “Two and two make four and cannot by any possibility that the universe affords be made to make five or three. From this point of view, of immutable law, children should approach Mathematics; they should see how impressive is Euclid’s ‘Which is absurd,’ just as absurd as would be the statements of a man who said that his apples always fell upwards, and for the same reason.”

           — Charlotte Mason, Towards a Philosophy of Education

          “Most remarks made by children consist of correct ideas badly expressed. A good teacher will be wary of saying ‘No, that’s wrong.’ Rather, he will try to discover the correct idea behind the inadequate expression. This is one of the most important principles in the whole of the art of teaching.”

           — W. W. Sawyer, Vision in Elementary Mathematics

          • Tip: If you’re not sure how to draw out your child’s reasoning, read Christopher Danielson’s wonderful examples and advice on talking math with your kids: Talking Math with Your Kids.

          Continue reading Charlotte Mason Math: Practical Tips for a Living Math Education

          Charlotte Mason Math: Wrong Answers and Slovenly Teaching

          "Playing with the kittens" painting by Emile Munier, public domain

          The second place where a surface-level reading of Charlotte Mason’s books can lead to misunderstanding involves the treatment of wrong answers. Mason wrote:

          “… quite as bad as these is the habit of allowing that a sum is nearly right, two figures wrong, and so on, and letting the child work it over again. Pronounce a sum wrong, or right — it cannot be something between the two. That which is wrong must remain wrong: the child must not be let run away with the notion that wrong can be mended into right.”

           — Charlotte Mason, Home Education

          Does this call to mind images of your own childhood schoolwork? It does for me: laboring over a worksheet or quiz and then taking it to my teacher to be graded. Right was right, and wrong could not be mended. In such a performance-oriented setting, mistakes can take on the flavor of moral failure.

          Is this authoritarian approach the way Mason wants us to teach math to our children? Where is the summa corda — the joyful praise — in that?

          No. Please, no. Very definitely no.

          Mason wanted us to avoid slovenliness in our teaching. In this passage, she warned against several forms this might take.

          Continue reading Charlotte Mason Math: Wrong Answers and Slovenly Teaching

          Gratis Games and Playful Math News

          Get your free copy today!
          Do you want to help your children learn math?

          Teach them to play.

          Grab a free copy of my Let’s Play Math Sampler: 10 Family-Favorite Games for Learning Math Through Play, which contains short excerpts from my most popular titles. It’s a great way to get started with playful math. 😍

          As a bonus, I’ll add you to my Playful Math News email subscription and send you monthly tips and activity ideas for playing math with your kids.

          From time to time, I’ll even throw in a free sample of whatever I’ve been working on — an early draft of something that will eventually show up in one of my books or printable activity guides.

          For example, check out this fun freebie I sent last April:

          Don’t miss out on all this mathy goodness. Sign up today!

          Get the Games Book Now